CMSC 304
Ethics and Social Issues in Information Technology
Topic Selection and Reading Assignment
handed out on Wed Sep 4, 2013, due on Mon Sep 16, 2013
http://www.cs.umbc.edu/CMSC304/Fall2013/topics.html
In-Class Activity: Topic Selection
Today we'll be selecting topics for the reading-based discussions
that will take up most of our class time during the semester.
On each of these topic-based days, there will be some associated
reading assignment (to be completed before class),
one or more students assigned to give a brief overview
presentation (signup will be forthcoming once the topics
are selected), and an in-class discussion, debate, or other
activity. We may also have guest speakers for some topics.
At the end of this assignment are two lists: a list of tentative
topics that I included in the initial class schedule, and another
list of topics that I thought might also be interesting.
Your assignment today is to work with your teams to make and
prioritize a list of topics for the class. You should be
thinking about several decision criteria:
- What topics are of most interest to us as students, users, and future
CS professionals?
- What topics will generate interesting and lively discussion that
we'd like to participate in?
- What topics are about the right scope for one day's worth of
assigned reading and one class period's worth of discussion and
debate? (Some narrow topics could be grouped together; broad
topics could be subdivided into different perspectives or issues.)
- What set of topics would create diversity and let us explore
a wide range of issues and topics? (We could talk about privacy and
security all semester, but perhaps that would get a bit dull.)
- What set of topics represents a mix of things you are already
familiar with and new topics?
- What set of topics represents a mix of technical and non-technical,
deep and not-as-deep topics? As in all things, variety is the spice
of life.
It's fine to use your laptops to explore the Internet for possible
reading assignments and to learn more about the topics, to see
whether they'll be interesting in practice. You can also get
started on the reading assignment that's due next week (see below).
Here's the intended schedule for today's class:
- 7:00-7:15 - Distribution and discussion of assignment, questions
answered, move into groups.
- 7:15-7:45 - Team discussion and prioritization. You should
end up with a ranked list of topics (you don't have to include
every topic on the list, but should have at least 10-15 so you
don't run out during the voting phase).
- 7:45-8:15 - Topic voting. Each team proposes the first topic
on their ranked list (moving to the 2nd or later topics if another
team has already proposed that topic). There will then be a few minutes
for each team to reorder their list if they want to, in response to
the set of topics that's been chosen. This voting process will
continue until we have at least 17 topics (the number of days
allocated to topic-based discussions). We may then have time for
some discussion/debate/negotiation about the list overall.
I'll take this list and use it to establish the final topic schedule
(topics and dates) after class, and will post this schedule on the
course website (replacing what's there now).
I reserve the right to adjust the list of topics if I think
essential topics have been left off the list, if there is too much
duplication, or if I see other problems with the generated list.
I'll also keep a couple of topics in reserve in case the schedule
shifts.
Assignment: Reading Selection
Each student must pick at least two topics
from the selected list and submit at
least two solid reading assignments for each of those topics.
One of the two assignments for a given topic can be a video.
Note that I will make the final reading assignments (which will
be posted on the website), but these will largely be drawn
from your selections.
By "solid," I mean that the assigned readings/videos
must be of reasonable length and have fair
amount of technical and thoughtful content. A half-page lightweight
piece or 90-second youtube video doesn't count, although some set of those
might be equivalent to one solid assignment.
Team Option: If you wish, your team (or a subset of your
team) may work together on this assignment. In that case, if you
have N students working together, you must pick at least 2N topics,
and must include at least two reading assignments for each topic.
Your suggested readings should be submitted on Piazza,
as a PDF or plain text. The submission
should list each topic, with the readings collected under
the topic. Each reading should include an article/video title,
author (or publishing
organization), and URL (if available) or other source (if not
available online).
You may also include a brief
explanation of why you think the readings would be appropriate
for the class. If you work in a group, only one person
should submit the assignment, and it MUST include the list of
members!
Topics from Tentative Class Schedule
- Software development and reuse
- Software licensing models
- Copyright and trademark issues
- Patents
- Security of personal computers
- Cyberterrorism and large-scale security
- Personal privacy - search, social networking, HIPAA
- Data mining and information privacy
- Free speech and censorship
- Green computing
- Computational sustainability
- Work issues: Automation and worker displacement
- Work issues: Working conditions
- Accessibility - American Disabilities Act
- Women representation in computing
- Sharing/Piracy of copyrighted content (music, movies, books)
- Entrepreneurship
- AI applications
- AI - robot ethics
Other Topics to Consider
- Technology "haves" and "have-nots", rights to access
- Plagiarism and citing the work of others
- Gender and minority underrepresentation in CS
- Accessibility - bioinic limbs
- Voting: voting technology, ORCA, Karl Rove alleged vote rigging
- Digital retouching of images and videos
- Smart wallets (security, spending habits)
- Online credit card security and e-tailing
- Gaming addictions and Internet addictions
- Video games in general
- Violence in video games
- Sexism and racism in video games
- Google Earth, Google street view, and privacy/surveillance
- Internet vigilantism
- Use of cell phone cameras in public, semipublic, private places
- Cyberstalking
- Phone usage and texting while driving (distracted driving)
- Self-driving cars
- Blogging and libel/privacy issues
- Online education and MOOCs
- Patriot Act and warrantless wiretapping/government access to
cell phone content
- How are you protected? Laptop password/security, smartphone
password/security, Facebook password/privacy/security, other
online accounts
- Telemedicine and telesurgery
- Nanotechnology, biosensors
- "Jailbreaking" and rights of purchasers to own/modify technology
- WikiLeaks
- Aaron Swartz's suicide
- Digital copyright/piracy/SOPA
- Online protests/denial of service acts
These are the topics selected by the class on Wed Sep 4, 2013. This is the
topic list to use for the Reading Selection assignment. Again, I will make the
final topic and reading selections. I will post them on the website on the
schedule page.
Class Selected Topics
- Personal privacy - search, social networking, HIPAA
- Copyright and trademark issues
- Sharing/Piracy of copyrighted content (music, movies, books, 3D printing)
and enforcement policies and issues
- "Jailbreaking" and rights of purchasers to own and modify technology
- Warrantless wiretapping and government access to cell phone content
and other data
- Nanochips in soilders - Biomedical engineering AI in medicine
- Digital currency (Bitcoin and others)
- Smart wallets (security, spending habits)
- Cyberterrorism and large-scale security
- Free speech and censorship
- AI - robot ethics
- Internet vigilantism and Hacktivism
- Electronic voting
- Work issues: Automation and worker displacement
- Green computing
- Data mining and information privacy
- Smart grid data mining
- Violence in video games
- Pornography
- Phishing and spamming